Why locals rank it above Flamenco
Flamenco Beach earned its fame; Discovery Channel once named it the second best beach in the world. It is also what fame does to a beach: parking lots, food kiosks, and a thousand towels on a Saturday.
Culebrita is what Flamenco was before the world found it. No road reaches it, so the crowd is whoever fit on a handful of small boats. The water over Tortuga's reef runs clearer because nothing drains into it and no one churns it up.
Flamenco Beach still earns the trip. TripAdvisor puts Flamenco Beach in the top ten beaches in the world, and National Geographic, CN Traveler, and Lonely Planet have all named it among the most beautiful on Earth. The water is calm, the sand is bone white, and there is no equivalent on the Puerto Rico mainland.
Alvin puts it simply: Flamenco is the beach you show visitors. Culebrita is the beach we keep for ourselves. This trip is us handing it over for a day.